Picture perfect partner?

By Rob Spray, September 2009

In a funny way, the camera wasn’t the biggest news in the Olympus E-620 review bundle. The unassuming, though admittedly cobby, Olympus UFL-2 has been something which I and a lot of other nerds have been waiting for. It’s nothing more or less than the first completely dedicated digital flash for diving. You can house every land model under the sun but I don’t think anyone else has done the job this way – properly.

To understand how interesting this is, you have to know that an awful lot of underwater photography is still conducted essentially manually. The flashes, or strobes as divers like to call them, are simply triggered at a preset power and the camera is adjusted to match. Even TTL, which is de facto on the surface, is often a bit suspect where it is implemented. Features like focal plane shutter lighting are almost unheard of. The very idea of a zoom headed flash is something I haven’t heard discussed? A lot of this is because, although cameras have advanced at an alarming pace, much of the underwater flash market is still languishing in filmic nostalgia.

The UFL-2 is a dedicated zoom headed strobe
The UFL-2 is a dedicated zoom headed strobe

I haven’t seen what the list price of this strobe will be. Unfortunately I know it will be a shock for land photographers. All strobes are expensive compared with their land counterparts. There’s a lot of engineering required to make anything waterproof – this unit down to 60m – and even more to manage the heat trapped in a waterproof case. The UFL-2 will take up a mid market position, not the most powerful unit but probably the most flexible strobe on the market. Not cheap but good value considering the features which it packs in.

Rich inheritance

The Olympus UFL-2 picks up its rich feature set for free because it is, actually, Olympus’ FL-36 mid range flash made watertight. The style of case suggests that Olympus supplied the insides and Sea and Sea made the casing. There’s no shame in that, Sea and Sea are the biggest makers of diving strobes and are very good at it. It’s more of a surprise that they didn’t try to cram it into one of their existing housings, but I guess it was the zoom head that dictated the chunky outline. A slight disappointment is that despite the plump body, they didn’t find space for more batteries. It takes two AA’s but looks as though it would have been trivial to fit four in. More batteries would mean longer between refills and faster recovery.

For an underwater flash the Olympus UFL-2 has rather a lot of controls, all lifted from the FL-36. Apart from the obvious Power button, there’s Mode, Zoom and Backlight – for the display. It needs the display because unlike most underwater flashes it can be configured quite extensively, and the backlight is a good idea as the display is inset so that it’s tricky to read in less than perfect light.

There's a connector for wired control as well as optical
The front fibre port allows complete control via wireless RC mode

The mode button is the key to setting the strobe, but once set you could leave it forever and not bother it again. The button cycles through its many modes; Manual, Auto, TTL Auto, FP TTL Auto, FP Manual, Slave Auto and Slave Manual. Some are only available when a camera is connected – as there’s a dialogue through the hotshoe which tells the camera what the flash is ready to do and the camera tells the flash what zoom position the lens is in. It sounds complicated, but in reality you choose a mode and use it. It’s just that unlike a normal strobe, there are more than two choices.

Zoom zoom

The zoom head is a novel arrival on the underwater market. Strobes traditionally advertise their wide angle coverage, to suit ultra wide angle lenses (and to make aligning them easier). Although the Olympus UFL-2 is comparatively small, the guide number of 36m is apparently much more powerful than some extremely large competing strobes. That figure is when the head is zoomed in; the intensity falls as the beam spreads. At its widest the power drops to a still-competitive 20m, although the coverage is narrower than many mid range strobes claim. The head automatically zooms with the lens and provides matched coverage from 12mm to 42mm – the clip on diffuser spreads the coverage.

On land the FL-36 knows when its slide out diffuser is in use, but as you have to manually fit the one for the UFL-2 it just has to try its best – not a problem, that’s what flashes do anyway. Coverage is pretty good, losing out a little to other strobes at wide angle but spilling a lot less light around macro subjects.

Kate meets a lobster and the UFL-2 lights a wide angle scene
Kate meets a lobster and the UFL-2 lights a wide angle scene

It’s a double edged sword. The zoomed beam is much more difficult to aim but much more efficient. Even at 42mm the beam is significantly wider than the macro set up I normally use (70mm), but a strobe is used on long flexible arms and has to be aimed. As it isn’t wasting light covering the vast majority of the scene you aren’t interested in, the meagre battery reserves are spared. Cycling can be near instantaneous for macro because of this efficiency.

Flash cycling takes a hit if you use the FP modes, which allow the use of shutter speeds up to 1/4000th with most 4/3 cameras (1/8000 with the E-3 or E-30). This mode emits a series of light pulses to cover the sensor as the shutter opening moves and simply can’t fire at full power multiple times, so the amount of light is reduced and recovery times are longer. For this I wish they had shoe horned a bigger battery compartment into the case. You might wonder why this feature is valuable, very simply it increases the options for macro with black backgrounds.

Remotely interested

The strobe has the standard Olympus 5 pin connector for cabled connection to any housing which has a matching bulkhead connector to carry the hotshoe connection through the case. It’s a simple and quite hardy set up which we’ve used for more than 5 years now. In the very early days others had some issues with ungreased metal bulkhead connectors, but they were soon changed. Now they are all polycarbonate threaded – which can’t seize.

This may now be a moot point as the UFL-2 can also be controlled optically. All Olympus SLRs (and their ultra zoom compacts) have offered this system for a while now. The pop up flash on the camera uses data bursts of light to signal its intentions to the strobe and the flash responds with infra red. The pop-up flash doesn’t light the scene. I’ve used this protocol underwater with the FL-36R (in the PFL-02 case) and found that in open water the control range was limited, which is why the UFL-2 and PT-E06 have matching ports for optical fibres. This makes the control connection as reliable as wire – but with no vulnerability to water :-) Very bad news for sales of replacement strobe cables!

The control of a dedicated strobe helps expose this Janolas nudibranch
The control of a dedicated strobe helps expose this Janolas nudibranch

Once set to RC Slave, the system works as though it’s wired, except all flash control is brought onto the back of the camera. It’s pretty cool, you don’t have to peer into the strobe’s display to find out what’s going on. From the camera back panel you can select any of the modes and control 3 channels of apparently unlimited flashes. In real life I guess two is practical, but it does open up the option of some very complicated multiple flash lighting.

The Olympus UFL-2 can of course also trigger third party strobes, either in manual or auto slave modes. You can’t use the second port on the case for this in RC mode as the control pulses would falsely trigger the strobes, but the UL-2 has a second port which can daisy chain the main flash to trigger another.

There’s a small price to pay in that the camera uses its own flash to control the strobe, reducing battery life, but the data bursts don’t have to be very powerful so the impact is slight.

Conclusion

As I’ve used a housed FL-36 for a couple of years I knew exactly how the UFL-2 would behave. It’s not the most powerful strobe in the world but it has superb finesse – wired or fibre connected. Control on macro subjects is excellent, if you wanted to you could correctly expose subjects actually resting on the strobe itself. For wide angle shooting, the control options the RC wireless mode offers are potentially mind numbing, but it actually really simplifies the addition and use of multiple extra strobes.

TTL control makes shots like this Mantis a doddle (relatively  speaking!)
TTL control makes shots like this Mantis a doddle (relatively speaking!)

Housing the FL-36 properly has made it very pleasant to use – a land flash with the form factor of a typical underwater strobe. Almost nothing is lost from the FL-36 and now it is easier to aim and much, much lighter. Even though they have certainly not rushed to market, Olympus have beaten the bigger players to offering a truly complete underwater SLR system by miles.

One of the unexpected bonuses of the wireless remote mode is that this strobe can do duty on land too, if you need to add another flash to your set up, or want to play in the rain. Most TTL strobes are confined to underwater use by their specialist connectors.

Pros:

Very fully featured, superb exposure control, zoom head, full wireless control. Very high power for macro at small apertures.

Cons:

Only 2 AA batteries, limited reserves and recycle slows as batteries deplete. Wired connector could be positioned better. Not cheap.

Ratings

  • Build: 9/10 Shame the wired connector wasn’t better sited
  • Performance: 9/10 Mega macro, needs a friend for ultra wide
  • Value: 8/10 Ultimate flexibility at a reasonable price, for a strobe

Overall:

The Olympus UFL-2 is now the best strobe for Olympus macro divers.

Read Rob’s review of the Olympus E-620 digital SLR.
Read Rob’s review of the Olympus PT-E06 waterproof housing.


  • In reply to your opening paragraph. Ikelite have manufactured dedicated underwater strobes for a long time and they do it a lot better than Olympus. The DS range are far better constructed and offer true TTL operation – Olympus’s fibre optic connection cannot do this.

  • I know what you mean, but that’s not what I’m suggesting. An underwater strobe is not the same as a dedicated flash. It does not include the advanced functions you’d expect of a modern flash or allow the control that a modern SLR offers over a flash. The Olympus RC system is full TTL in all modes with sync at all speeds and total control of the flash – it is an optical version of wired control. The Ikelite system is a translation, not native dedicated control and adds another point of failure to camera systems which already have their own TTL protocols. That is not to diminish the awesome high power and wide angle strobes that they make or suggest that they are not well made.but if you handled one you would see that the The UFL-2 is as well made as any Sea and Sea strobe (who clearly developed the casing) but also has all the functions of a dedicated land flash including a zoom head and sync speed at up to 1/4000th of a second – via wire or fibre. Via fibre you can if you choose control 3 groups of flashes in any mix of focal plane TTL, auto TTL or manual all from the back of the camera. It’s very good.

    The Ikelite units are certainly designed from the outset as strobes rather than flashes but they are not dedicated much further than offering a ready light and a quench control. The housings are arguably dedicated but a modern land flash includes many functions which require a digital dialogue and I would be interested to learn of other options which include that.

    Regards

    Rob

  • Pingback: Lighting links this week()

  • Pingback: Olympus E-620 Review | Wex Photographic()

  • Pingback: Olympus PT-E06 Review | Wex Photographic()

  • Pingback: Taking SLRs Underwater – Part 2 | Wex Photographic()

  • Bryce DeMann

    The strobe automatically adjusts the flash with the 14-42, Will it work with the 9-18mm and a domed port the same way?

  • Hi Bryce,
    The strobe is zoom headed and can cover 12-42mm lens angles – and will do that automatically when wired/ manually when fibred. With a diffuser fitted it should cover out to 8mm.
    Regards
    Rob

  • Tim Priest

    Rob’s strictly accurate above: the Inon Z240 and D2000 strobes (you can tell an underwater photographer because we never say “flash”) use TTL emulation but their performance is better than the Olympus and their flexibility rather greater, particularly with several stops of variable power. In Europe Inon strobes are rather more popular than Ikelite, and retain their usefulness if the budding underwater photographer “trades up” to a DSLR system, still almost entirely represented by only Nikon and Canon cameras.

  • Hi Tim,
    Thanks for the balance. I’d always seek to provide context if making a statement like ‘their performance is better than’ – in this case the Inons recycle faster at high power and provide a wider beam. They have a higher guide number for wide coverage but cannot narrow their beam (you can mask it with a snoot of course) where the UFL-2 has a higher guide number. When asked I do express my preference for the UFL-2 for macro but explain that for wide shooting Inon are superb. I have other strobes I use for wide angle :-)

    As for flexibility. The UFL-2 can run Auto or Manual when triggered as a slave. It doesn’t mimic TTL so it doesn’t offer that choice with non Olympus cameras. It can be used in a 3 channel system via fibre with Olympus cameras, supports flash speeds above mechanical sync (for large sensor cameras) and its control is integrated with the camera – which isn’t an option with other strobes. Output power can be controlled in fractional steps, absolutely in manual mode or relatively in automated modes. So for versatility with an Olympus SLR there isn’t much to touch it. Other strobes take a more generic approach, they can do less with more cameras. You pays your money and takes your choice. I hope that seems balanced, I don’t think there’s a perfect strobe available but most have merits.

  • I like your review Rob, its nice to see you waving the Olympus flag so vigorously. We at OLC love the EPL3 it represents extraordinary value for money at the moment.
    However whilst the UFL-2 is a technical tour de force with its wireless RC and FP flash sync (being able to synchronise throughout the shutter speed range) Its worth pointing out that this particular aspect which on first glance is extraordinarily useful to UW toggers, becomes much less practical when you consider that it dramatically reduces the output to achieve this, and saps the juice too.. Add this to the fact that it only has two AA’s and it becomes a great idea poorly realised. Not unlike running a Ferrari on a cupful of petrol.
    Practicality is always going to win over bells and whistles, if it was running on 4 AA’s then maybe, but what were they thinking? I bet it was one of those things where the aesthetic design dept won out over the technical designers, sadly to the detriment of what could have been a fab piece of kit, and almost worth the price they ask. No at the moment Inon of course for size and weight and the new Sea and Sea YS D1 as the best bang for buck, IMHO of course ;)

  • Philip Martindale

    Hello,

    You seem to really know your way around the UFL 2 ! I have it set up on an EPM 1 and cannot figure out how to set it up correctly with the camera ! Auto, TTL Auto, FP TTL Auto, FP Manual, Slave Auto and Slave Manual….you seem to say that they all work with the Fibre Optic cable but I can’t figure it out. Damn Olympus manuals are hopelessly disingenuous – whether for the camera or the flash. There should be a walk-you-through guide for such a considerable investment, yet they give you nothing ! I am getting no rear flash panel / camera panel communication and, for example, what zoom setting do you use if using the 14mm – 42mm zoom ?? This is unbelievably frustrating and Olympus offer no guides to explain all the combinations possible and window information whether camera side or flash side. Do you know of any “guide” out there so that I may learn to know what I should be seeing on both camera and flash depending on the various settings ? For example, you mention RC slave mode – I can see the RC window or the Slave window but flash is different when I switch between the two ? I can’t see any combined RC Slave setting anywhere ! I’m pulling my hair out as I have great equipment and it’s about as user friendly as Olympus’ manuals. Hopeless….

  • Hi Philip,
    Hopefully I can help… The UFL-2 will work with any Pen or OMD – the key thing is that both the camera and strobe must be set to RC mode flash. RC doesn’t work in iAuto mode.

    On the camera, in camera menu 2, set RC Mode to ‘on’,
    – tap the shutter so it’s ready to shoot.
    – if you press OK the INFO button will cycle ‘Super Control Panel’ and flash control.
    – Check it is set for Ch 1 Group A, TTL and plain flash (not FP) for a start.

    On the strobe, set RC Mode to ‘on’
    – the strobe should display which channel and group – which must match the camera
    – zoom is normally the only manual control, set it to match the lens unless you want to snoot the lighting.

    In this set up, with a fibre between the two, the strobe will follow the flash settings on the camera – made via whichever UI you choose – eg SCP or short cut keys – whether TTL, Manual, +/- etc.

    Lighting underwater is trick so make sure you’re happy on land! Once it works next time you just turn it on.

    Rob

  • Pingback: Olympus TG-810 Review | Wex Photographic()

  • evil bob

    I just purchased a TG4. I’m confused with the wireless and fiber opt. I’m not interested in the underwater housing but need an extra flash for abandoned mines. Waterproof is a must for a strobe/flash. Can I place a strobe on some rocks and step/float back and snap a picture with my TG4. Do this wireless with no Fiber optic.